Cheaper alternatives to Podere Il Carnasciale Il Caberlot

Separated at birth. We found 3 dupes — same taste profile, same swagger, minus the prestige markup.

The splurge

Podere Il Carnasciale Il Caberlot

2009 · Toscana, Italy · Red blend

BodyTanninAciditySweetnessFruit

€140

The steal

Dead ringer

Podere Monastero Campanaio

Toscana, Italy · Red blend

Shared Cabernet Sauvignon in the blend. Same Toscana postcode. Same dark-fruit core. About 33% of the price.

€46 save €94

Full comparison Save to cellar

Save to cellar Full comparison

Prices are typical retail, checked Sep 2026 — the retailer has the last word.

• Dead ringer
  Villa Patrizia 4-20 Merlot

  Toscana, Italy · Red blend

  Shared Cabernet Sauvignon in the blend
  €49

  save €91
  Compare Save
• Dead ringer
  Poggio Lauro Gran Vecciano Edizione Limitata

  Toscana, Italy · Red blend

  Shared Cabernet Sauvignon in the blend
  €22

  save €118
  Compare Save

• Castello di Montepó Sassoalloro Oro€34 → €12
• Tenuta di Carleone Il Guercio€59 → €20
• Uccelliera Toscana Rapace€39 → €16
• Fattoria Aldobrandesca Aleatico Toscana Rosato€43 → €16
• Barbanera Gigino 80 Anniversario Grande€29 → €6
• Monteverro Chardonnay Toscana€105 → €41
• Guado al Melo Jassarte€36 → €14
• Podere Forte Guardiavigna€199 → €55

See every Toscana dupe →