Best Toscana dupes

The top 48 of 86 Toscana splurges, each with a taste-matched twin at a fraction of the price. The prestige markup never stood a chance.

Dead ringer

Antinori Tignanello

2016 · €312 · our pick: Antinori Villa Antinori Rosso at €31

€31

save €281

See the dupes →
Close cousin

Antinori Villa Antinori Rosso

€31 · our pick: Velenosi Brecciarolo Rosso Piceno Superiore at €10

€10

save €21

See the dupes →
Dead ringer

Ornellaia Le Volte

€26 · our pick: Ponte Lungo Curioso at €9

€9

save €17

See the dupes →
Dead ringer

Tenuta San Guido Guidalberto

€69 · our pick: Ornellaia Le Volte at €26

€26

save €43

See the dupes →
Dead ringer

Gaja Ca'Marcanda Promis Toscana

€54 · our pick: Tenuta Castiglioni Toscana at €16

€16

save €38

See the dupes →
Close cousin

Tenuta San Guido Le Difese

€30 · our pick: Vinyes Domenech Bancal del Bosc Tinto at €12

€12

save €18

See the dupes →
Dead ringer

Tenuta Luce Lucente

€35 · our pick: Poggio delle Faine Toscana at €14

€14

save €21

See the dupes →
Dead ringer

Antinori Tenuta Tignanello 'Solaia'

2009 · €682 · our pick: Tenuta CastelGiocondo Lamaione Toscana at €59

€59

save €623

See the dupes →
Dead ringer

Biserno Il Pino di Biserno

€54 · our pick: Castello di Gabbiano Dark Knight Toscana Red at €15

€15

save €39

See the dupes →
Dead ringer

Masseto Toscana

2006 · €2208 · our pick: Gaja Ca'Marcanda Promis Toscana at €54

€54

save €2154

See the dupes →
Dead ringer

Montevertine Le Pergole Torte

2018 · €269 · our pick: Bibi Graetz Soffocone di Vincigliata Toscana at €46

€46

save €223

See the dupes →
Dead ringer

Castellare Toscana I Sodi di San Niccolo

€74 · our pick: Petrolo Toscana Torrione at €28

€28

save €46

See the dupes →
Dead ringer

Brancaia Ilatraia

€55 · our pick: Poggio Lauro Gran Vecciano Edizione Limitata at €22

€22

save €33

See the dupes →
Dead ringer

Gaja Ca'Marcanda Vistamare Toscana

€60 · our pick: Belguardo Vermentino Bianco Toscana at €13

€13

save €47

See the dupes →
Dead ringer

Cabreo Il Borgo Toscana

€45 · our pick: Castello di Montepó Braccale Rosso at €16

€16

save €29

See the dupes →
Dead ringer

Banfi SummuS

€50 · our pick: Petra HEBO (Suvereto) at €15

€15

save €35

See the dupes →
Dead ringer

Castello Nipozzano Mormoreto Toscana

€55 · our pick: Banfi Belnero (Proprietor's Reserve) at €21

€21

save €34

See the dupes →
Dead ringer

Il Borro Toscana

€69 · our pick: Tolaini Tenuta San Giovanni Valdisanti at €25

€25

save €44

See the dupes →
Close cousin

Petrolo Toscana Torrione

€28 · our pick: Di Majo Norante Sangiovese at €9

€9

save €19

See the dupes →
Dead ringer

Caiarossa

€74 · our pick: Petra Potenti Toscana (Suvereto) at €29

€29

save €45

See the dupes →
Dead ringer

Biserno

2020 · €169 · our pick: Villa Patrizia 4-20 Merlot at €49

€49

save €120

See the dupes →
Close cousin

Fattoria le Pupille Poggio Valente

€33 · our pick: Garofoli Rosso Conero Piancarda at €12

€12

save €21

See the dupes →
Dead ringer

Ornellaia Poggio alle Gazze

€61 · our pick: Tenuta Montecchiesi Vermentino - Chardonnay at €14

€14

save €47

See the dupes →
Dead ringer

Petra

€60 · our pick: Poggio Lauro Gran Vecciano Edizione Limitata at €22

€22

save €38

See the dupes →
Dead ringer

Tua Rita Redigaffi Toscana

2017 · €231 · our pick: Biserno Il Pino di Biserno at €54

€54

save €177

See the dupes →
Dead ringer

Le Macchiole Messorio

2015 · €258 · our pick: Villa Patrizia 4-20 Merlot at €49

€49

save €209

See the dupes →
Close cousin

Bibi Graetz Soffocone di Vincigliata Toscana

€46 · our pick: Boscarelli Toscana de Ferrari at €12

€12

save €34

See the dupes →
Close cousin

Castello Nipozzano Montesodi Toscana

€35 · our pick: Duca di Saragnano Sir Passo Toscana at €13

€13

save €22

See the dupes →
Dead ringer

San Giusto a Rentennano Percarlo

2022 · €100 · our pick: Guado al Melo Jassarte at €36

€36

save €64

See the dupes →
Dead ringer

Capannelle Solare Toscana

€59 · our pick: Banfi Belnero (Proprietor's Reserve) at €21

€21

save €38

See the dupes →
Dead ringer

Castello di Ama L'Apparita

2006 · €404 · our pick: Cabreo Il Borgo Toscana at €45

€45

save €359

See the dupes →
Dead ringer

Tenuta del Nicchio Lodovico

2017 · €512 · our pick: Villa Patrizia 4-20 Merlot at €49

€49

save €463

See the dupes →
Dead ringer

Fonterutoli Concerto Di Fonterutoli

€58 · our pick: Banfi Belnero (Proprietor's Reserve) at €21

€21

save €37

See the dupes →
Dead ringer

Tenuta CastelGiocondo Lamaione Toscana

€59 · our pick: Poggio Lauro Gran Vecciano Edizione Limitata at €22

€22

save €37

See the dupes →
Dead ringer

Poliziano Le Stanze Toscana

€47 · our pick: Castello di Gabbiano Dark Knight Toscana Red at €15

€15

save €32

See the dupes →
Dead ringer

Castello dei Rampolla d'Alceo

2001 · €240 · our pick: Il Borro Toscana at €69

€69

save €171

See the dupes →
Close cousin

Uccelliera Rosso di Montalcino

€28 · our pick: Mesa Primo Scuro at €11

€11

save €17

See the dupes →
Dead ringer

Le Boncie Le Trame Toscana

€66 · our pick: Caiarossa Pergolaia at €24

€24

save €42

See the dupes →
Close cousin

Avignonesi Toscana Grifi

€35 · our pick: Duca di Saragnano Sir Passo Toscana at €13

€13

save €22

See the dupes →
Dead ringer

Tenuta di Trinoro Toscana Rosso

2009 · €514 · our pick: Brancaia Ilatraia at €55

€55

save €459

See the dupes →
Close cousin

Caiarossa Aria di Caiarossa

€34 · our pick: Tenuta Ammiraglia Terre More Maremma Toscana at €12

€12

save €22

See the dupes →
Dead ringer

Soldera Case Basse Sangiovese Toscana

2019 · €1388 · our pick: Terra Nera Scorpus at €47

€47

save €1341

See the dupes →
Close cousin

Petra Potenti Toscana (Suvereto)

€29 · our pick: 19 Crimes The Banished Dark Red at €10

€10

save €19

See the dupes →
Dead ringer

Monteverro Toscana

2018 · €186 · our pick: Biserno Il Pino di Biserno at €54

€54

save €132

See the dupes →
Close cousin

San Felice Pugnitello

€49 · our pick: Petra HEBO (Suvereto) at €15

€15

save €34

See the dupes →
Dead ringer

Podere Il Carnasciale Il Caberlot

2009 · €140 · our pick: Podere Monastero Campanaio at €46

€46

save €94

See the dupes →
Close cousin

Castello di Montepó Sassoalloro Oro

€34 · our pick: Argiolas Perdera Monica di Sardegna at €12

€12

save €22

See the dupes →
Dead ringer

Tenuta di Carleone Il Guercio

€59 · our pick: Terenzi Purosangue Morellino di Scansano Sangiovese Riserva at €20

€20

save €39

See the dupes →